Sunday, June 14, 2026

The 70%: The shared beliefs of Evangelical Protestants and Roman Catholics

Last year I read an article that stated Protestants and Catholics are in agreement on 70% of their beliefs. I’ve decided that, as time allows, I am going to explore and write about the beliefs that Evangelical Protestants and Catholics have in common. I am focusing specifically on Evangelical Protestantism because I have experience in this particular fellowship. I’m in the research phase right now, but I plan to use a variety of materials and sources. I especially want to interview converts, both Catholic-to-Protestant and Protestant-to-Catholic. I will be doing a lot of reading as well, starting with the list below.

I am a cradle Catholic but from 1986-2000, I worshipped in Protestant Evangelical churches (Assemblies of God and Pentecostal Holiness) and heard many testimonies from ex-Catholics. I returned to full communion with the Catholic Church in the fall of 2000, and since that time I’ve immersed myself in the testimonies of former Protestants who converted to Catholicism.
In the last few months, I have felt more and more that the rift between these two groups seems to be growing wider, especially when it comes to the division between Evangelical (Born Again) Christians and the growing number of Catholics choosing a more traditional Catholic worship (e.g., pre-Vatican II Latin Tridentine Mass, reception of communion by mouth and kneeling at altar rail).

I have one more reason for deciding to write about this topic, a deeply personal one that probably sounds rather childish on my part. It bothers me very much, even feels like a knife through my heart, when I hear or read the following sentiment:

CATHOLICS AREN’T CHRISTIANS.

Perhaps I should just ignore this statement when I run across it, or develop a thicker skin. The differences exist and, given my personal experiences and faith walk, are hard for me to ignore. My experience in Evangelical Christian church worship taught me so much and actually played a large role in my return to a Catholic faith experience that is now much deeper and more authentic than I ever thought possible. My life as a Catholic is no longer the rote, lukewarm, half-hearted nod of respect to my Catholic parents and schooling that it was in my younger years.

I can no longer view my Evangelical and Catholic faith experiences as two distinctly separate paths. Without my Catholic upbringing and excellent Catholic education based on faith and reason, I would not have begun my search for a deeper relationship with Jesus Christ that led me to charismatic, evangelical Christianity. Had I not worshipped in the evangelical church where I learned the importance of scripture study, vibrant fellowship, personal witness, sharing testimonies, and being on fire for Jesus, I would not be where I am today, which is exactly where the Holy Spirit has led me. This is the reason that I want to write about the beliefs that these two branches of Christianity have in common.

Jesus Christ. He is the reason for everything I am and everything thing I believe. So, I’ll start my journey with Jesus. Are Catholics and Evangelical Protestants in agreement about Him?

Pray for me,
Rosie

Some sources I’ll be looking at:



The latest from Rosie

My Sacred Path Home

Hi, I'm Rose. I am a cradle Catholic who left the Catholic church in 1985 and attended evangelical churches for 16 years. I returned to ...